Lane Gilchrist · Reaction-diffusion · draft 13 Nov 2026

Which reaction-diffusion parameters does the MES literature report?

A spatial reaction-diffusion model of an electrode biofilm needs transport, structure and kinetic parameters measured on the same system. This page counts how often the literature on microbial electrochemical systems (MES) reports each one next to a measured outcome, names the gaps, and proposes what to build.

ProposalNothing is fitted. Every number is a paper-level count from MESSAI’s public parameter export (committed Oct 27, 2026): a lower bound, not an effect estimate.

The question

Can a reaction-diffusion model of an electrode biofilm be parameterised from the literature?

Not yet. Of 11 parameters such a model needs, the most reported one appears in 27 of 7,885 papers, and the diffusion coefficient has no entry of its own.

The export holds 196,522 extracted values from 7,885 papers with a DOI.

Parameter map

Eleven parameters against three outcomes. Select a cell to see what the parameter does in a model, how often it is reported and why it is a gap.

no paper1–2 papers3–9 papers10 or more

Each cell: papers that report the parameter and that outcome. Select a cell for the detail.

Parameter · papersCurrent densityPower densityCoulombic efficiency
Diffusion coefficient *9
Mass-transfer coefficient3
Tortuosity *0
Biofilm thickness14
Biofilm porosity15
Biofilm density12
Biofilm conductivity2
Average pore size12
Specific surface area27
Half-saturation constant6
Specific growth rate15

* No canonical parameter exists; matched by reported name. “Usable” counts values with a canonical parameter, an SI value in a plausible range and a passed check. Across the whole export: current density 799 papers, power density 1,316, coulombic efficiency 755.

Three gaps

  1. Diffusion has no entry

    No canonical parameter exists for a diffusion coefficient. Matching by reported name finds 52 values in 9 papers, with species and medium unrecorded and none usable for modeling. Tortuosity: 0 values.

  2. Conduction is nearly absent

    Biofilm conductivity is reported by 2 papers (5 values, 0 usable for modeling).

  3. Evidence split across spellings

    3 of the 11 parameters are stored under two spellings, so a query on one sees part of the evidence. The counts on this page merge them.

Open puzzles

Questions the export cannot answer today, with what it holds and what would settle each.

  1. Is an anode biofilm limited by substrate diffusion or by electron conduction?

    The answer needs three numbers from one biofilm: thickness, the substrate’s diffusion coefficient inside it, and conductivity. Thickness is reported by 14 papers, conductivity by 2, a diffusion coefficient by 9, a mass-transfer coefficient by 3. Papers reporting all three: 1.

    Would settle it: the three measured on one biofilm, then the ratio of reaction rate to diffusion rate (Thiele modulus).

    Start a hypothesis from this puzzleOpen its protocol steps in the builder

    Cross-section of an anode biofilmAn electrode on the left carries a biofilm; liquid lies to the right. Substrate diffuses from the liquid through the biofilm towards the electrode. Electrons are conducted through the same biofilm to the electrode. One dimension line marks the biofilm thickness, which is both the diffusion length and the conduction length.ElectrodeBiofilmLiquidSubstrate: diffusionElectrons: conductionBiofilm thickness L= diffusion length = conduction length
    Schematic, not to scale.
  2. How far does a secreted flavin carry electrons inside a pore?

    Shewanella oneidensis secretes flavins that carry electrons to the electrode (Marsili et al. 2008). The reach depends on pore geometry, the flavin’s diffusion coefficient and the transfer rates at cell and electrode. The export has 38 values naming a flavin, from 10 papers, and no flavin diffusion coefficient.

    Would settle it: a particle-based simulation (MCell) in a measured pore geometry, compared with a continuum model using the same parameters.

    Start a hypothesis from this puzzleOpen its protocol steps in the builder

    A flavin shuttling between a cell and the electrode in a poreA pore between two electrode walls holds one cell. A flavin is reduced at the cell, diffuses across the gap to the electrode wall, is oxidised there and diffuses back. A dimension line marks the gap between cell and electrode with the question how far.ElectrodePoreElectrodeCellFlavin: diffusionreduced at the celloxidised at the electrodediffusion backHow far?
    Schematic, not to scale.
  3. Do the pores an electrode reports leave room for its biofilm?

    Pore size is reported by 12 papers and biofilm thickness by 14. Papers reporting both: 2. The pore explorer computes the wall area a cell can reach for a chosen smallest pore, but its scans are of a carbon black / PTFE electrode layer and platinum-catalyst particles, not of an MES anode.

    Would settle it: an open tomogram of carbon felt or carbon cloth, with biofilm thickness measured on the same material.

    Start a hypothesis from this puzzleOpen its protocol steps in the builder

    The same biofilm in a wide pore and in a narrow poreTwo pores in one electrode, lined by a biofilm of the same thickness. In the wide pore the biofilm covers both walls and an open channel for liquid remains. In the narrow pore the same biofilm fills the pore and no channel is left. Dimension lines mark the pore size of each pore and the biofilm thickness.Pore sizePore sizeElectrodeBiofilm thicknessopen channel for liquidno channel left
    Schematic, not to scale.

Models

The cell the biofilm sits in, and three anode materials with the pore-scale numbers a model needs.

Where the biofilm sits

Microbial fuel cell (MFC)

A biofilm on a graphite-brush anode oxidises the substrate; the electrons run through an external load to an air cathode. Substrate diffuses in from the liquid and electrons travel out through the biofilm, so both lengths are set by its thickness. Example geometry. Drag to orbit.

Microbial fuel cell (MFC)

Anode microstructure: the electrode side of the model

Porosity and permeability set how liquid moves through the electrode; tortuosity sets effective diffusion; specific surface sets how much area a biofilm can colonise. The values below are textbook ranges, shown to mark what a measured scan would replace.

Example literature ranges (example data): not measured, not simulated

Carbon felt

literature range
PropertyValue · Range
Porosity0.930.9–0.96
Tortuosity1.81.4–2.6
Specific surface30,000square metres per cubic metre10,000–100,000
Permeability3.00e-10square metres1.00e-10–1.00e-9
Thickness5millimetres4–6

Manufacturer datasheet range (SGL / Sigracell felt series); specific surface is a geometric estimate from fibre diameter; illustrative

Carbon cloth

literature range
PropertyValue · Range
Porosity0.80.75–0.85
Tortuosity1.51.2–2
Specific surface100,000square metres per cubic metre50,000–200,000
Permeability2.00e-11square metres1.00e-11–1.00e-10
Thickness350micrometres300–500

Typical woven PAN carbon cloth range (0.3 to 0.5 mm); permeability is an order-of-magnitude estimate between paper and felt; illustrative

Graphite fibre brush

literature range
PropertyValue · Range
Porosity0.960.95–0.98
Tortuosity1.51.2–2
Specific surface16,000square metres per cubic metre5,000–50,000
Permeability1.00e-8square metres1.00e-9–1.00e-7
Thickness30millimetres20–100

Typical graphite fibre brush range; specific surface quoted per brush volume; thickness is the brush envelope diameter and varies widely by design; illustrative

Measured pore geometry in place of textbook values: the pore explorer.

Measured pore geometry

Electrode tomograms, coloured by local pore diameter. Drag to orbit; pick a scan to change scale.

Carbon black / PTFE electrode layer

Vulcan XC / PTFE · Pore network

Loading the scan…

These are analogue scans, not a microbial-electrochemical anode: a carbon black / PTFE electrode layer and platinum-catalyst particles on carbon. The library holds no scan of a felt, cloth or brush anode and none of a biofilm.

Open the full explorer: slices, size distribution, pore network and transport

Two organisms, two transport problems

The first two puzzles are each about one organism.

  • SEM micrograph of Geobacter sulfurreducensMicrograph

    Geobacter sulfurreducens PCA

    Transfers electrons directly: outer-membrane cytochromes and conductive protein filaments carry them through the biofilm to the electrode.

    Puzzle 1. Its biofilms grow tens of micrometres thick, so electron conduction and substrate diffusion compete over the same length.

    Open the field guide
  • SEM micrograph of S. oneidensis MR-1Micrograph

    Shewanella oneidensis MR-1

    Transfers electrons through outer-membrane cytochromes and through secreted flavins that diffuse between cell and electrode.

    Puzzle 2. The flavin is a diffusing mediator that reacts at two surfaces: a reaction-diffusion problem inside the pore.

    Open the field guide

Protocol: growing and measuring an anode biofilm

11 steps from the protocol graph. Select a step for its measurements, equipment and references; the detail opens on the right.

Loading the protocol graph…

Click a step for its measurements, equipment, precautions and references. Drag to pan.Open the full protocol graph →

Of the map’s parameters these steps record one: biofilm thickness, by confocal z-stack in the imaging step. No step in the protocol graph records a diffusion coefficient or biofilm conductivity.

Open these steps in the protocol builder

What MESSAI would build

  1. A diffusion-coefficient entry with species and medium

    Proposed

    Add a canonical diffusion coefficient that records the diffusing species and the medium (water, biofilm, membrane), and merge the 3 parameters stored under two spellings.

  2. A targeted extraction

    Proposed

    Re-read the 9 papers that name a diffusion coefficient and the 10 that name a flavin. Store each value with its DOI and the sentence it came from.

  3. A Thiele modulus in the pore explorer

    Proposed

    The Electron transfer tab of the pore explorer reports penetration depth and supply limit. Add the Thiele modulus from the same inputs, so the page states whether diffusion or reaction limits.

  4. Scan geometry for MCell

    Proposed

    Export each scan as a surface mesh that CellBlender imports, with a parameter file listing every value and its source.

  5. Two protocol steps

    Proposed

    Add steps to the protocol graph for measuring biofilm conductivity and an effective diffusion coefficient, each with method, equipment and references.

Live pages

What already exists, in the order to open it.

  1. Pore explorer — Four measured tomograms, from a 42 µm electrode layer to a 22 nm catalyst support, cut open in 3D. The Electron transfer tab links pore geometry to current.
  2. Geobacter sulfurreducens PCA — Growth and electron-transfer kinetics. Every value carries its paper, DOI, source sentence and check result.
  3. Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 — The same page where the evidence is thin.
  4. Methodology — The mass-transport and electron-transfer equations, with porosity and permeability per electrode medium.

What we ask of you

  • A tomogram. Do you know an open micro-CT scan of carbon felt or carbon cloth?
  • Which coefficients first. Which species and media matter most: acetate in biofilm, oxygen in water, flavins, protons?
  • MCell input. Which mesh and parameter format would you load into CellBlender without rework?
  • Outside MES. Is there a reaction-diffusion model of yours for which a sourced parameter table would help? The method is the same.
  • The puzzles. Are these three the right ones, and which would you pose differently?

Source: open-source/mess-parameters/data/extracted-parameter-data.csv (committed Oct 27, 2026, sha256 19cc46604d51) · measured Nov 13, 2026 with scripts/collab/measure-transport-coverage.py