Research

Paper · MEC

Ammonium Recovery and Biogas Upgrading in a Tubular Micro-Pilot Microbial Electrolysis Cell (MEC)

01

Summary

What the paper reports, in its own words.

3D Interactive ModelAI Enhanced· 78%Resource Recovery

Abstract

Here, a 12-liter tubular microbial electrolysis cell (MEC) was developed as a post treatment unit for simultaneous biogas upgrading and ammonium recovery from the liquid effluent of an anaerobic digestion process. The MEC configuration adopted a cation exchange membrane to separate the inner anodic chamber and the external cathodic chamber, which were filled with graphite granules. The cathodic chamber performed the CO2 removal through the bioelectromethanogenesis reaction and alkalinity generation while the anodic oxidation of a synthetic fermentate partially sustained the energy demand of the process. Three different nitrogen load rates (73, 365, and 2229 mg N/Ld) were applied to the inner anodic chamber to test the performances of the whole process in terms of COD (Chemical Oxygen Demand) removal, CO2 removal, and nitrogen recovery. By maintaining the organic load rate at 2.55 g COD/Ld and the anodic chamber polarization at +0.2 V vs. SHE (Standard Hydrogen Electrode), the increase of the nitrogen load rate promoted the ammonium migration and recovery, i.e., the percentage of current counterbalanced by the ammonium migration increased from 1% to 100% by increasing the nitrogen load rate by 30-fold. The CO2 removal slightly increased during the three periods, and permitted the removal of 65% of the influent CO2, which corresponded to an average removal of 2.2 g CO2/Ld. During the operation with the higher nitrogen load rate, the MEC energy consumption, which was simultaneously used for the different operations, was lower than the selected benchmark technologies, i.e., 0.47 kW/N·m³ for CO2 removal and 0.88 kW·h/kg COD for COD oxidation were consumed by the MEC while the ammonium nitrogen recovery consumed 2.3 kW·h/kg N.

AI summary

78% confidence

A 12-liter tubular MEC with cation exchange membrane was operated as a post-treatment unit for anaerobic digestate, coupling biogas upgrading (CO₂ removal via bioelectromethanogenesis) with ammonium recovery. Three nitrogen loading rates (73–2229 mg N/Ld) were tested at fixed anode potential (+0.2 V vs. SHE) and organic load (2.55 g COD/Ld). Ammonium migration through the membrane increased dramatically with N load, from 1% to 100% of ionic current, enabling recovery of up to 2.5 g N/day. CO₂ removal remained stable (~450 mmol/day, 65% removal). Energy consumption for N recovery was 2.3 kWh/kg N, competitive with benchmark technologies.

Key insights

  • Threshold Ammonium contribution to ionic current increased non-linearly with influent concentration: 5-fold increase in N load (73→365 mg N/Ld) caused 22-fold increase in transported charge (1%→22%), while 30-fold increase (73→2229 mg N/Ld) caused only 100% increase (1%→100%).

    So what. Operators should expect saturation of ammonium-driven ionic transport at high N loads; design catholyte spill rates accordingly to avoid exceeding electroneutrality capacity.

  • Trade-off Coulombic efficiency (CE) dropped from 77% at low N load to 18% at high N load (73→2229 mg N/Ld), while COD removal efficiency increased from 29% to 70%, indicating non-electroactive COD removal pathways (sorption, biofilm entrapment) became dominant.

    So what. At high ammonium loads, do not assume all COD removal is electrochemical; account for biomass growth and physical sorption when calculating electron balance and energy efficiency.

  • Trade-off Cathodic capture efficiency (CCE) peaked at 98% during the middle N-load period (365 mg N/Ld) but dropped to 81% at the highest load (2229 mg N/Ld), despite stable methane production rate (14±2 mmol/day).

    So what. High ammonium loads may reduce cathodic current utilization efficiency; monitor CCE as an early indicator of cathode performance degradation or competing reactions.

  • Mechanism Cell voltage decreased from −2.66 V at low N load to −1.48 V at high N load, a 44% reduction, while current remained relatively stable (190→157 mA), indicating improved ionic conductivity from ammonium migration.

    So what. Increasing ammonium concentration reduces ohmic losses; design power supplies for lower voltage requirements when treating high-N digestates, improving energy efficiency.

  • Threshold No inhibition of methanogens or electroactive biofilm was observed even at 1341 mg N/L influent ammonium (2229 mg N/Ld load), and no ammonia was detected in outlet gas, indicating complete retention and recovery.

    So what. Ammonium concentrations up to ~1000 mg N/L are tolerable in MEC anodes; design recovery systems to capture all migrated ammonium in catholyte spill to prevent ammonia volatilization.

Contradictions1

Tensions the paper itself points to. Each side quotes the passage it comes from.

  • Within the paper COD removal efficiency increased sharply while coulombic efficiency decreased sharply at the highest N load, suggesting a decoupling of electrochemical and total COD removal.

    One side

    COD removal efficiency increased to 89±20% at 2229 mg N/Ld

    “The increase of the COD removal efficiency up to 70% probably indicated an underestimation of the biomass growth in the anodic chamber or the presence of non-electroactive COD removal pathways like COD sorption or entrapment in the biofilm mat”
    Other side

    Coulombic efficiency dropped to 18±2% at the same condition

    “the CE of the process, which was only 18 ± 2%”

    Authors’ reading. Authors attribute the discrepancy to biomass growth and non-electroactive sorption/entrapment, implying that total COD removal includes both electrochemical oxidation (low CE) and physical/biological processes (high removal efficiency). This is mechanistically plausible but not quantitatively resolved in the paper.

Opportunity areas6

Specific gaps in this paper, with an experiment that would close each.

  • High No measurement of nitrite (NO₂⁻) or nitrate (NO₃⁻) accumulation in anode or cathode across any N-load condition; denitrification or nitrification pathways not characterized.

    Paper focuses on ammonium recovery but does not report whether any N oxidation or reduction occurs. At anode potential +0.2 V vs. SHE, nitrification is thermodynamically possible; at cathode, denitrification could compete with methanogenesis.

    Try. Measure NO₃⁻, NO₂⁻, N₂O, and N₂ in anode and cathode effluent and gas phases across all three N-load periods; use ¹⁵N tracing if needed.

  • High No systematic variation of anode potential; only +0.2 V vs. SHE tested. Operating window for ammonium recovery vs. nitrification not explored.

    Paper states anode was 'maintained' at +0.2 V but does not justify this choice or test alternatives. Higher potentials might suppress ammonium migration or promote nitrification; lower potentials might reduce current.

    Try. Test anode potentials from −0.1 to +0.4 V vs. SHE at fixed N load (e.g., 365 mg N/Ld); measure ammonium migration rate, current, and any N-oxide formation.

  • Medium Catholyte pH not actively controlled; ranged 7.5±1 across periods. Effect of pH on ammonium speciation (NH₄⁺ vs. NH₃) and migration not isolated.

    At pH 7.5, ~99% of total ammonia is NH₄⁺, but pH drift could shift this. Paper does not report pH control strategy or sensitivity analysis.

    Try. Operate at fixed pH (6.5, 7.0, 7.5, 8.0) in cathode; measure ammonium migration rate and N₂O/NH₃ emissions.

  • Medium Hydraulic retention time (HRT) fixed at 0.52 days; no variation tested. Effect of HRT on ammonium removal efficiency and N-species selectivity unknown.

    Paper states HRT was 0.52 d but does not explore shorter or longer residence times. Shorter HRT might reduce ammonium removal; longer HRT might enable denitrification.

    Try. Test HRT 0.25, 0.52, 1.0, 2.0 days at fixed N load and anode potential; measure N removal efficiency and N-species balance.

  • High No N₂O measurement or quantification; only CO₂, CH₄, and H₂ reported in gas phase. N₂O emissions from cathode (denitrification) or anode (nitrification) not ruled out.

    Bioelectrochemical systems can produce N₂O as a byproduct of denitrification or nitrification. Paper does not report whether N₂O was measured or below detection limit.

    Try. Analyze cathode and anode gas outlets for N₂O using GC-ECD or IRMS; quantify N₂O production rate as function of N load and potential.

  • Medium Biomass composition and electroactive biofilm characterization not reported; only VSS measured. Microbial community structure and electron transfer mechanisms not identified.

    Paper reports VSS in anode effluent (84–106 mg/L) but does not characterize biofilm on electrodes or identify key electroactive taxa. Mechanism of ammonium tolerance unclear.

    Try. Perform 16S rRNA gene sequencing and FISH on anode and cathode biofilms at each N-load period; measure extracellular electron transfer rates via cyclic voltammetry.

Generated by MESSAI extraction pipeline · review against source PDF

02

Extracted values

Every value pulled from the paper, with its source, so each number can be checked against the text.

n = 60 extracted values

Select a citation to see the quote, page and confidence behind a value.

13 of 59 extracted rows modelable

  • 2 not canonicalised (no canonical slug)
  • 41 no SI value
  • 3 outside physical bounds
ParameterValueUnitConfidenceSourceNotesModelable
Coulombic efficiency1%80%
llm
Specific Energy Consumption0.72kW·h/Nm3 CO₂90%
energy balance
"kW·h/Nm3 CO2 0.72 ± 0.07" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.5, substrate=co2Excluded: no SI value
Voltage-2Outside physical range, check sourceV90%
potentiostatic measurement
"The cell voltage applied between the anode and cathode was on average −2.00 ± 0.…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.1, substrate=volatile_fatty_acids_mixtureExcluded: outside physical bounds
Current Density (Basis Unresolved)166mA90%
potentiostatic control
"an average electric current of 166 ± 10 mA was obtained with a consumption of 4.…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.1, substrate=volatile_fatty_acids_mixtureExcluded: no SI value
Specific Energy Consumption2.3kW·h/kg N90%
energy balance
"kW·h/kg N 2.3 ± 0.5" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.1, substrate=volatile_fatty_acids_mixtureExcluded: no SI value
Nitrogen Removal3,250mg N/day90%
mass balance
"the daily nitrogen removal was on average 3246 ± 558 mg·N/d" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.1, substrate=volatile_fatty_acids_mixtureExcluded: no SI value
CH₄ Production Rate9mmol/day90%
gas chromatography
"The main product detected in the cathodic chamber, as reported in Figure 4, was …" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.5, substrate=co2Excluded: no SI value
Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) Removal6.3g COD/day90%
mass balance
"the COD removal shown in Figure 3 increased to 6.3 ± 0.6 g COD/day" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.1, substrate=volatile_fatty_acids_mixtureExcluded: no SI value
Cathodic Current Efficiency81%90%
electron balance
"which resulted in an average CCE value of 81 ± 14%" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.5, substrate=co2Modelable
CH₄ Production Rate14mmol/day90%
gas chromatography
"the methane production rate was almost stable, with an average value of 14 ± 2 m…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.5, substrate=co2Excluded: no SI value
Substrate Concentration37mg N/L90%
nessler method spectrophotometry
"the average influent ammonium concentration was 37 ± 2 mg·N/L" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.1, substrate=volatile_fatty_acids_mixtureExcluded: no SI value
Nitrogen Removal713mg N/day90%
mass balance
"by the daily removal of 713 ± 150 mg·N/day" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.1, substrate=volatile_fatty_acids_mixtureExcluded: no SI value
Substrate Concentration674mg N/L90%
nessler method spectrophotometry
"The concentration of the ammonium in the cathodic chamber (Figure 5) was 674 ± 4…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.5Excluded: no SI value
Substrate Concentration101mg N/L90%
nessler method spectrophotometry
"an ammonium concentration of 101 ± 9 mg·N/L in the cathodic chamber" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.5Excluded: no SI value
Substrate Concentration25mg N/L90%
nessler method spectrophotometry
"the average effluent ammonium concentration was 25 ± 2 mg·N/L" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.1, substrate=volatile_fatty_acids_mixtureExcluded: no SI value
Current Density (Basis Unresolved)190mA90%
potentiostatic control
"the average electric current was 190 ± 14 mA, which was generated by an average …" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.1, substrate=volatile_fatty_acids_mixtureExcluded: no SI value
Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) Removal4g COD/day90%
mass balance
"an average electric current of 166 ± 10 mA was obtained with a consumption of 4.…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.1, substrate=volatile_fatty_acids_mixtureExcluded: no SI value
Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) Removal481mmol/day90%
gas chromatography
"The daily CO2 removal obtained in the cathodic chamber was on average 443 ± 40, …" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.5, substrate=co2Excluded: no SI value
Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) Removal443mmol/day90%
gas chromatography
"The daily CO2 removal obtained in the cathodic chamber was on average 443 ± 40, …" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.5, substrate=co2Excluded: no SI value
Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) Removal453mmol/day90%
gas chromatography
"The daily CO2 removal obtained in the cathodic chamber was on average 443 ± 40, …" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.5, substrate=co2Excluded: no SI value
Substrate Concentration241mg N/L90%
nessler method spectrophotometry
"the influent and effluent ammonium concentration in the anodic chamber was 241 ± 14…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.1, substrate=volatile_fatty_acids_mixtureExcluded: no SI value
Substrate Concentration2,090mg N/L90%
nessler method spectrophotometry
"The concentration of the ammonium ion in the catholyte during the last operating…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.5Excluded: no SI value
Alkalinity11.4g HCO₃⁻/L90%
toc analyzer
"the cathodic bicarbonate concentration showed similar concentrations of 10.94 ± …" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.5Excluded: no SI value
Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) Removal65%90%
mass balance
"the COD removal efficiency increased to 65 ± 17%" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.1, substrate=volatile_fatty_acids_mixtureModelable
Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) Removal70%90%
mass balance
"The increase of the COD removal efficiency up to 70%" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.1, substrate=volatile_fatty_acids_mixtureModelable
Showing 25 of 60

Literature priors

Distribution

Against the literature

The author’s reported value (▼) sits on top of the literature distribution from MESS-Parameters. Values outside the band are flagged as outliers.

Coulombic efficiency1percent

Methodology

What was the system and how was it run

Methodology

Methodology

A 12-liter tubular MEC with concentric chambers separated by a cation exchange membrane (Fumasep FKS-PET, 2355 cm² area) was operated in potentiostatic mode with the anode at +0.2 V vs. Ag/AgCl reference electrode. The anode chamber (3.14 L working volume) was fed continuously with a synthetic VFA mixture (acetate, propionate, butyrate) at 6.9±0.2 L/day (HRT 0.52 d) and inoculated with activated sludge. The cathode chamber (5.06 L working volume) was fed with a 30% CO₂ / 70% N₂ gas mixture at 45 L/day and inoculated with anaerobic sludge. Three nitrogen loading rates (73, 365, 2229 mg N/Ld) were applied sequentially by adjusting influent ammonium concentration. Liquid samples were analyzed for COD (GC-VFA), ammonium (Nessler method), and bicarbonate (TOC analyzer); gas samples were analyzed for CH₄, CO₂, and H₂ by GC. Current, voltage, and daily catholyte spill volume were monitored continuously.

System configuration

FieldValue
reactor typeMEC
chamber config2-chamber

Electrode specifications

FieldValue
materials["graphite"]

Performance metrics

FieldValue
coulombic efficiency1
citation count20

Operating conditions

3 runs extracted
RunT°CpHanpHcatSubstrate[S]mg/LHRThModeR_extΩV_appVInoculum
v2-114c42b5b00dfa98257.1—volatile_fatty_acids_mixture780———0.2—
v2-376b4b3ae80d2ad4257.5——————0.2—
v2-d2df3861d7a5d413257.5—co2————0.2—

Outcomes

What was measured and what worked

Key takeaways

Coulombic efficiency

electrochemistry

1percent

Pipeline

Raw extractions, artifacts, quality signal

Extraction quality

honesty signal

Calibrate your trust in the extracted content against these signals — they're how the pipeline rated its own output for this paper.

Parameter completeness

50%

Fraction of expected parameters extracted

Data completeness

60%

Overall extraction coverage across fields

AI confidence

78%

Model self-reported confidence

Mean parameter confidence

86%

Average confidence across PaperParameter rows surfaced above

review against source PDF before citing · scores 0–1

03

Chart explorer

Move the inputs this paper used and see how the predicted outcome shifts.

04

Explore model

The reactor in 3D, with flow you can switch on and off.

05

AI insights

Contradictions, gaps and opportunities found by comparing this paper with the corpus.

06

Compare similar papers

The nearest papers by system, materials and organisms, with their outcomes side by side.

07

Source PDF

The paper as published.

loading 3D model…

Representative model, generic MEC

Representative MEC — matched on the paper’s system type only, not its reactor or geometry.

MEC
System
77.0percent
Best result · Coulombic efficiency
best of 4
60
Extracted values
2020
Year

In this record

Organisms, parameters and materials this paper reports. Each links to its page.

Parameters · 1

Keywords

  • Microbial electrolysis cell
  • Electrolysis
  • Biogas
  • Ammonium
  • Anode
  • Anaerobic digestion

Cite

Lorenzo Cristiani, Marco Zeppilli, Cristina Porcu et al. (2020). Ammonium Recovery and Biogas Upgrading in a Tubular Micro-Pilot Microbial Electrolysis Cell (MEC). Molecules. https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules25122723

Journal
Molecules

Open in lab for full controls, parameter editing, and template overlays.

Open in lab