Paper · MFC
Simultaneous Removal of Trivalent Arsenic and Nitrate Using Microbial Fuel Cells
Summary
What the paper reports, in its own words.
Abstract
A rectangular double chamber with trivalent arsenic as the electron donor of the biological anode was constructed by microbial fuel cells (MFC), and the feasibility of the MFC simultaneous degradation of trivalent arsenic and nitrate was studied. Experimental results show that the co-matrix-coupled MFC reactor oxidizes trivalent arsenic in an anode chamber and degrades nitrate in the cathode chamber. The removal rate of trivalent arsenic is about 63.35%, and the degradation rate of nitrate is about 55.95% during the complete and stable operation period. MFC can continuously output electric energy, and the maximum output voltage is 388 mV. We compared and analyzed the main functional microflora of biofilm microorganisms in an anode chamber. In the long-term arsenic-polluted environment, the activity of Acinetobacter, Pseudomonas bacteria with arsenic resistance, was improved. It is inferred that a fraction of trivalent arsenic was oxidized to pentavalent arsenic by electrode-attached microorganisms. While remaining trivalent, arsenic was taken up by the suspended bacterial biomass and converted into stable arsenide. The results of this study have theoretical reference value for the expansion of the MFC application scope.
AI summary
82% confidenceThis study demonstrates simultaneous As(III) oxidation and NO₃⁻-N reduction in a two-chamber MFC, achieving 63.45% As(III) removal and 55.95% NO₃⁻-N degradation with 388 mV output. However, As(III) presence severely inhibited electrical performance (37% power density loss, 40% internal resistance increase) and shortened cycle duration from 88 h to 27 h. Microbial analysis revealed As(III) selectively enriched arsenic-resistant Acinetobacter and Petrimonas while suppressing Geobacter (0.7% vs 3.71% in control), explaining the performance penalty. The cathode accumulated NH₄⁺-N (57.2 mg/L) and transient NO₂⁻-N (6.45 mg/L), indicating competing DNRA and denitrification pathways with minimal Anammox activity.
Key insights
Trade-off As(III) presence reduced maximum power density by 37.2% (574.3 vs 915.1 mW/m³) and increased internal resistance by 39.8% (280 vs 201 Ω), despite maintaining functional As oxidation at 63.45% removal.
So what. If As(III) co-contamination is unavoidable, design for lower current density targets and accept shorter operational cycles; consider anode pre-acclimation or selective biofilm enrichment to mitigate toxicity.
Trade-off Cathode NO₃⁻-N degradation rate was 1.69 mg/(L·h) in MFC-As but only 0.85 mg/(L·h) in control, yet final NO₃⁻-N was higher (35.9 vs 5.91 mg/L) because MFC-As cycle ended 61 h earlier, demonstrating that faster instantaneous rate does not compensate for shortened operational window.
So what. Do not optimize for instantaneous degradation rate alone; measure total nitrogen removed per cycle and account for cycle duration when comparing MES configurations.
Mechanism Geobacter abundance dropped to 0.7% in MFC-As versus 3.71% in control, while Petrimonas increased from 0.2% to 2.49%, indicating As(III) selectively suppresses the primary electroactive genus and enriches hydrogen-producing fermentative bacteria.
So what. Pre-enrich or immobilize Geobacter on the anode before As(III) exposure, or operate at lower As(III) concentrations (<20 mg/L) to preserve electroactive biomass.
Mechanism NH₄⁺-N accumulated to 57.2 mg/L in MFC-As cathode (vs 25.44 mg/L in control) while Anammox relative abundance was only 0.1% (vs higher in control), indicating DNRA dominance over complete denitrification and minimal N₂ production.
So what. If N₂ recovery is the goal, suppress DNRA by maintaining higher cathode potential or dissolved oxygen; if ammonia recovery is desired, exploit this DNRA-dominant regime but manage pH to prevent volatilization.
Threshold NO₂⁻-N peaked at 6.45 mg/L in MFC-As at 4 h then became negligible, whereas in control it peaked at 7.61 mg/L at 23.1 h, suggesting As(III) accelerates nitrite turnover but does not prevent transient accumulation.
So what. Monitor NO₂⁻-N in early operation (0–6 h) when As(III) is present; transient accumulation may indicate incomplete denitrification or Anammox limitation rather than system failure.
Contradictions1
Tensions the paper itself points to. Each side quotes the passage it comes from.
Within the paper As(III) increases instantaneous NO₃⁻-N degradation rate but decreases total NO₃⁻-N removal per cycle
One sideAverage NO₃⁻-N degradation rate in MFC-As is 1.69 mg/(L·h), higher than control at 0.85 mg/(L·h)
“the average degradation rate in the cycle was about 1.69 mg/(L*h)”
Other sideFinal NO₃⁻-N concentration in MFC-As is 35.9 mg/L (55.95% removal) versus 5.91 mg/L in control (92.71% removal) because cycle duration is only 27 h vs 88 h
“the concentration of NO3−-N in the water sample of the cathode solution was 5.91 mg/L, the degradation rate was about 92.71%”
Authors’ reading. The authors note that although instantaneous rate improves, the shortened cycle duration (61 h shorter) prevents reaching the same absolute removal percentage. This is a real trade-off: As(III) toxicity accelerates denitrification kinetics but shortens the operational window, resulting in net lower total removal.
Opportunity areas6
Specific gaps in this paper, with an experiment that would close each.
High No systematic variation of As(III) concentration (only 20 mg/L tested); threshold for Geobacter suppression and power loss is unknown
Section 3.1 and 3.3.2 show As(III) inhibits performance, but no dose–response curve is provided. The paper does not test whether lower As(III) (e.g., 5, 10 mg/L) would preserve Geobacter abundance and power output while still achieving acceptable As removal.
Try. Vary As(III) from 0 to 30 mg/L in 5 mg/L increments; measure power density, Geobacter %, and As(III) removal rate to identify the concentration threshold below which performance penalty is <10%.
High Cathode potential and dissolved oxygen not controlled or reported; unclear whether DNRA dominance is due to low potential or low DO
Figure 5 shows NH₄⁺-N accumulation and minimal Anammox, but the paper does not report cathode potential, DO, or pH. DNRA is favored at low potential and high DO; Anammox requires anoxia. Without these parameters, the mechanism driving nitrogen pathway selection is ambiguous.
Try. Operate MFC-As with controlled cathode potentials (−0.2, −0.4, −0.6 V vs Ag/AgCl) and measure NO₃⁻-N, NO₂⁻-N, NH₄⁺-N, and Anammox/DNRA gene abundance to deconvolve potential and DO effects.
High No measurement of N₂O or N₂ production; nitrogen mass balance incomplete
Section 3.2.2 states 'the sum of the NO2−-N, NH4+-N concentration, and total nitrogen concentration is significantly lower than the nitrogen content of the initial catholyte', implying N₂ or N₂O loss, but neither is quantified. This is critical for assessing whether denitrification is complete or incomplete.
Try. Measure headspace N₂ and N₂O by gas chromatography or membrane inlet mass spectrometry during the 27 h cycle; close the nitrogen mass balance and determine if N₂O accumulation occurs under As(III) stress.
Medium Anode HRT and C/N ratio not explicitly controlled or varied; acetate concentration fixed at 0.4 g/L COD
The paper uses a static batch system with 48 h solution changes until stable, then continuous operation, but does not report HRT or test different C/N ratios. Acetate is the primary electron donor, but its sufficiency for both As(III) oxidation and cathode reduction is not explored.
Try. Operate MFC-As with acetate concentrations of 0.2, 0.4, 0.8 g/L COD and measure As(III) removal, NO₃⁻-N removal, and power output to identify the optimal C/N ratio for dual-contaminant removal.
Medium Anode potential not reported; unclear whether As(III) oxidation is electrochemical or purely biological
Section 3.2.1 infers that 'a fraction of trivalent arsenic was oxidized to pentavalent arsenic by electrode-attached microorganisms' and another fraction is taken up by suspended biomass, but anode potential is not measured. The relative contribution of electrode-catalyzed vs. microbial oxidation is unknown.
Try. Measure anode potential vs Ag/AgCl during operation; compare As(III) oxidation rate at different anode potentials (0.0, +0.2, +0.4 V) to quantify the electrochemical vs. biological contribution.
Medium Single replicate per condition; no error bars or statistical significance testing reported
The paper presents one MFC-As and one MFC-control reactor with no replicates. All results (power, removal rates, microbial composition) are single measurements. Variability and reproducibility are unknown.
Try. Repeat MFC-As and MFC-control experiments in triplicate; report mean ± SD and perform ANOVA to confirm that observed differences (e.g., 37% power loss) are statistically significant.
Generated by MESSAI extraction pipeline · review against source PDF
Extracted values
Every value pulled from the paper, with its source, so each number can be checked against the text.
n = 43 extracted values
Select a citation to see the quote, page and confidence behind a value.
21 of 43 extracted rows modelable
- 18 not canonicalised (no canonical slug)
- 2 no SI value
- 2 contradicts other papers
| Parameter | Value | Unit | Confidence | Source | Notes | Modelable |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Substrate Concentration | 4.85 | mg/L | 95% | standard method for nh4+-n measurement | "After about 4 h, the NH4+-N concentration reached the lowest value of 4.85 mg/L …" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Modelable |
| Voltage | 419 | mV | 95% | voltage monitoring via data logger | "In the control group, the output voltage of the MFC reactor went through a logar…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Modelable |
| Nitrate Concentration (final, MFC-control) | 5.91 | mg/L | 95% | standard method for no3−-n measurement | "After running for about 89 h in the MFC-control group, the concentration of NO3−…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Nitrate Concentration (final, MFC-As) | 35.9 | mg/L | 95% | standard method for no3−-n measurement | "At the end of the production cycle of MFC-As, the lowest concentration of NO3−-N…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Operational Taxonomic Units | 2,970 | — | 95% | 16s rrna gene sequencing, otu clustering at 97% identity | "MFC-As (cathode) OTU number is 2970" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Modelable |
| Substrate Concentration | 25.4 | mg/L | 95% | standard method for nh4+-n measurement | "At the end of the production period (89 h), the NH4+-N concentration in the cath…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Modelable |
| Operational Taxonomic Units | 5.4 | — | 95% | 16s rrna gene sequencing, shannon diversity index calculation | "MFC-As (anode) Shannon index is 5.4" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Modelable |
| Substrate Concentration | 39.4 | mg/L | 95% | standard method for nh4+-n measurement | "At the beginning of the production cycle, the NH4+-N concentration in the cathol…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Modelable |
| Operational Taxonomic Units | 3,030 | — | 95% | 16s rrna gene sequencing, otu clustering at 97% identity | "MFC-control (cathode) OTU number is 3029" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Modelable |
| Operational Taxonomic Units | 2,580 | — | 95% | 16s rrna gene sequencing, otu clustering at 97% identity | "The minimum OTU number in the MFC-As anode compartment was 2582" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Modelable |
| Operational Taxonomic Units | 6.05 | — | 95% | 16s rrna gene sequencing, shannon diversity index calculation | "Raw sludge Shannon index is 6.05" · condition_hint=Raw sludge inoculum from Wangxiaoying Sewage Treatment Plant | Modelable |
| Operational Taxonomic Units | 2,960 | — | 95% | 16s rrna gene sequencing, otu clustering at 97% identity | "The original inoculated sludge OTU number used in the experiment was 2960" · condition_hint=Raw sludge inoculum from Wangxiaoying Sewage Treatment Plant | Modelable |
| Substrate Concentration | 57.2 | mg/L | 95% | standard method for nh4+-n measurement | "At 27 h, the concentration of NH4+-N in the catholyte water sample was 57.2 mg/L" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Modelable |
| Voltage | 388 | mV | 95% | voltage monitoring via data logger | "after MFC-As runs for about 5 h, the output voltage reaches a maximum value of 3…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Modelable |
| Nitrogen Removal | 0.616 | mg/(L*h) | 95% | multi n/c3100 analyzer | "The average removal rate in the control group was about 0.616 mg/(L*h)" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Excluded: no SI value |
| Nitrogen Removal | 0.425 | mg/(L*h) | 95% | multi n/c3100 analyzer | "The average removal rate of total nitrogen in the production cycle was about 0.4…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Excluded: no SI value |
| Shannon Diversity Index | 0.0256 | — | 95% | 16s rrna gene sequencing, simpson diversity index calculation | "MFC-As (anode) Simpson index is 0.0256" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Excluded: contradicts other papers |
| Production Cycle Duration (MFC-As) | 27 | h | 95% | voltage monitoring via data logger | "after MFC-As runs for about 5 h, the output voltage reaches a maximum value of 3…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Production Cycle Duration (MFC-control) | 88 | h | 95% | voltage monitoring via data logger | "The production cycle duration of the MFC-control was 88 h" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Trivalent Arsenic Removal Rate | 63.5 | % | 95% | high-performance liquid chromatography-hydride generation atomic fluorescence spectrometer | "In the cycle, the initial concentration of 20 mg/L of trivalent arsenic after th…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Trivalent Arsenic Concentration (final) | 7.31 | mg/L | 95% | high-performance liquid chromatography-hydride generation atomic fluorescence spectrometer | "the initial concentration of 20 mg/L of trivalent arsenic after the stability of…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Pentavalent Arsenic Concentration (final) | 5.13 | mg/L | 95% | high-performance liquid chromatography-hydride generation atomic fluorescence spectrometer | "The concentration of pentavalent arsenic in the anode solution increases gradual…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Trivalent to Pentavalent Arsenic Conversion Efficiency | 25.7 | % | 95% | high-performance liquid chromatography-hydride generation atomic fluorescence spectrometer | "The conversion efficiency of trivalent arsenic to pentavalent arsenic in the MFC…" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Total Arsenic Concentration (final) | 12.4 | mg/L | 95% | high-performance liquid chromatography-hydride generation atomic fluorescence spectrometer | "At the end of the electricity generation cycle, the concentration reaches 12.43 …" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Total Arsenic Removal Efficiency | 37.9 | % | 95% | high-performance liquid chromatography-hydride generation atomic fluorescence spectrometer | "the removal efficiency of total arsenic is approximately 37.85%" · T=25°C, pH(an)=7.4, substrate=acetate, steady_state | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
Methodology
What was the system and how was it run
Methodology
Methodology
Two-chamber MFC with carbon brush electrodes (80 mL each), separated by Nafion 117 membrane, operated in batch mode with 48 h solution changes until stable, then continuous operation under 1000 Ω load at 25°C. Anode fed 0.4 g/L acetate + 20 mg/L As(III) (MFC-As) or acetate alone (MFC-control); cathode fed 80 mg/L NO₃⁻ + 1 g/L NaHCO₃. Voltage logged every 2 min; polarization curves measured at stable maximum voltage. NO₃⁻-N, NO₂⁻-N, NH₄⁺-N, and total nitrogen quantified by standard methods; As species by HPLC-HG-AFS. Microbial community profiled by 16S rRNA gene sequencing (V3–V4 region, MiSeq) at end of cycle.
System configuration
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| reactor type | MFC |
| chamber config | 2-chamber |
Operating conditions
1 run extracted| Run | T°C | pHan | pHcat | Substrate | [S]mg/L | HRTh | Mode | R_extΩ | V_appV | Inoculum |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| v2-c6bcd0c97cdd2748 | 25 | 7.4 | — | acetate | 641 | — | steady_state | 1000 | — | — |
Pipeline
Raw extractions, artifacts, quality signal
Extraction quality
honesty signalCalibrate your trust in the extracted content against these signals — they're how the pipeline rated its own output for this paper.
AI confidence
82%
Model self-reported confidence
Mean parameter confidence
93%
Average confidence across PaperParameter rows surfaced above
review against source PDF before citing · scores 0–1
Chart explorer
Move the inputs this paper used and see how the predicted outcome shifts.
Explore model
The reactor in 3D, with flow you can switch on and off.
AI insights
Contradictions, gaps and opportunities found by comparing this paper with the corpus.
Compare similar papers
The nearest papers by system, materials and organisms, with their outcomes side by side.
Source PDF
The paper as published.
Representative model, generic MFC
Tap to interactRepresentative model, generic MFC
Representative MFC — matched on the paper’s system type only, not its reactor or geometry.
Keywords
- Arsenic
- Microbial fuel cell
- Nitrate
- Anode
- Microorganism
- Degradation (telecommunications)
Cite
Jing Guo, Jianping Cheng, Jiaquan Wang et al. (2021). Simultaneous Removal of Trivalent Arsenic and Nitrate Using Microbial Fuel Cells. Processes. https://doi.org/10.3390/pr9040673
- Journal
- Processes
Open in lab for full controls, parameter editing, and template overlays.
Open in lab