Paper · MEC
Improvement of biohydrogen production in microbial electrolysis cell (MEC) system by tackling methanogenesis
Summary
What the paper reports, in its own words.
Abstract
The increasingly adverse effects of climate change caused by a variety of fossil-based fuel demands an alternative to such fuel. Hydrogen is one of the potential renewable fuel that offers numerous advantages compared to its competitors. However, the dominant hydrogen production methods are still energy-heavy and dependent on fossil-based resources. Microbial electrolysis cell or MEC system is one of the leading solution towards replacing conventional hydrogen production method. A persistent downside to this system in the presence of methanogens that consumes the hydrogen product. This research proposes alternative biological method to control the methanogen colony by introducing isolates of denitrifying bacteria to the system which will act as inhibitor to hydrogenotrophic methanogen. The reactor implemented is a single-chambered, membrane-less 20-ml reactor. Net hydrogen yield produced in the cathodic headspace will be analyzed by gas chromatography (GC). Hydrogen yield for reactor with enriched cathode is expected to be higher in comparison to unenriched reactor, as nitrogen oxides produced during the metabolism of the denitrifiers were known to inhibit methanogen growth. Experimental results showed consistent higher H 2 yield in inoculated reactor compared to control reactor, where in the second cycle H 2 production increased 100% compared to the control.
AI summary
72% confidenceThis paper demonstrates that inoculating a single-chamber, membrane-less microbial electrolysis cell (MEC) with Pseudomonas stutzeri denitrifiers improves hydrogen production by suppressing methanogenesis. Operating at 0.7 V applied potential and 1 A supplied current in a 15 ml reactor, the denitrifier-inoculated reactor (A) achieved 100% higher H₂ yield in the second cycle (10.85% vs 5.60% H₂ composition) compared to uninoculated control (B), and sustained production across four cycles while control production declined. The mechanism is attributed to nitrogen oxide metabolites from denitrification inhibiting methanogenic activity, though direct verification was not performed. Results suggest biological competition via denitrifiers is a cost-effective alternative to ion-exchange membranes for methanogen control in membrane-less MECs.
Key insights
Performance Denitrifier-inoculated reactor A maintained H₂ production across four cycles (29.06% → 10.85% → 2.95% → 78.60% H₂ composition) while uninoculated control B declined after cycle 2 (24.63% → 5.60% → 0% → 0%), showing 100% improvement in cycle 2.
So what. Operators should inoculate membrane-less MECs with denitrifiers to achieve sustained H₂ production; uninoculated reactors lose productivity within 2–3 cycles under these conditions.
Threshold At 0.7 V applied potential, H₂ production occurred only in biologically active reactors (A and B) but not in sterile medium-only control (C), confirming the voltage is below the threshold for abiotic water electrolysis.
So what. This 0.7 V threshold is appropriate for small-scale MEC design; operators need not worry about competing abiotic H₂ production at this voltage in membrane-less reactors.
Method Faster headspace analysis interval (39 hrs vs 69 hrs in cycle 2) revealed the H₂ production advantage of the denitrifier reactor earlier and with higher resolution, enabling better discrimination of performance.
So what. For MEC optimization studies, use shorter sampling intervals (≤40 hrs) to detect performance differences before methanogenic consumption masks H₂ accumulation.
Mechanism Reactor A showed a dramatic H₂ spike in cycle 4 (78.60% composition after 71 hrs) following a low-production cycle 3 (2.95% after 46 hrs), attributed to recovery of surviving microorganisms after fresh medium addition.
So what. Nutrient depletion, not cell death, may limit H₂ production in cycles 3–4; frequent medium replacement (every 40–50 hrs) could sustain higher yields, but this trade-off against operational cost needs testing.
Contradictions3
Tensions the paper itself points to. Each side quotes the passage it comes from.
Within the paper Cycle 2 shows clear H₂ advantage for denitrifier reactor, but cycle 1 shows no predicted difference despite same conditions.
One sideCycle 1 (69 hrs): reactor A 29.06% H₂, reactor B 24.63% H₂ — 'the predicted production difference was not yet seen in this cycle'
“However, the predicted production difference was not yet seen in this cycle, which may be caused by either long reactor operation time that made H₂ evolution rate at a slower interval ot observed or simply that the methanogens have yet to b”
Other sideCycle 2 (39 hrs): reactor A 10.85% H₂, reactor B 5.60% H₂ — 'H₂ production is increased by 100%'
“This result proved the hypothesis in which the presence of the denitrifer inside the reactor is beneficial, in which in this case the H₂ production is increased by 100%.”
Authors’ reading. Authors attribute cycle 1 lack of difference to either slow H₂ evolution rate at long intervals or delayed methanogen activation; by cycle 2, methanogens became active and denitrifier inhibition became measurable. Shorter sampling interval (39 vs 69 hrs) also improved detection.
Within the paper Cycle 3 shows near-complete H₂ production failure in both reactors despite fresh medium, contradicting the expectation that nutrient replenishment would sustain production.
One sideCycle 2: reactor A 10.85% H₂, reactor B 5.60% H₂ — both producing
“Analysis of the headspace taken after 39 hrs of reactor operation is shown in Fig. 5 above. Chromatogram result for reactor C still did not yield any peak of hydrogen as predicted. As consequent analysis proved the premise that the voltage ”
Other sideCycle 3: reactor A 2.95% H₂, reactor B 0% H₂ — production collapsed despite fresh medium added
“Analysis of the headspace taken after 46 hrs of reactor operation is shown in Fig. 6 above. Only reactor A showed peak for hydrogen at around 0.6, with reactor A's headspace composed of 2.95% H2. H2 peak was not observed with reactor B. It ”
Authors’ reading. Authors attribute cycle 3 collapse to lag phase entry by denitrifiers or exoelectrogens due to nutrient depletion or accumulation of inhibitory metabolites, despite fresh medium addition. This suggests medium replacement alone is insufficient; the microbial community may require recovery time or removal of accumulated inhibitors (e.g., nitrite, N₂O).
Within the paper Cycle 4 shows dramatic H₂ recovery in reactor A (78.60%) after cycle 3 collapse (2.95%), but the mechanism is unclear and not fully explained.
One sideCycle 3: reactor A 2.95% H₂ after 46 hrs — production near zero
“Analysis of the headspace taken after 46 hrs of reactor operation is shown in Fig. 6 above. Only reactor A showed peak for hydrogen at around 0.6, with reactor A's headspace composed of 2.95% H2.”
Other sideCycle 4: reactor A 78.60% H₂ after 71 hrs — highest yield of all cycles
“Analysis of the headspace taken after 71 hrs of reactor operation is shown in Fig. 7 above. Although reactor B consistently yielded no peak for H2 akin to the previous cycle, hydrogen peak was observed yet again in reactor A. The headspace ”
Authors’ reading. Authors acknowledge the mechanism is unclear ('needs to be analysed further') and speculate that reduced microbial biomass combined with fresh medium enabled recovery. The 78.60% H₂ spike may reflect a transient condition (e.g., rapid H₂ accumulation before methanogenic consumption resumes) rather than sustained high production.
Opportunity areas6
Specific gaps in this paper, with an experiment that would close each.
High No measurement of nitrogen species (NO₃⁻, NO₂⁻, N₂O, N₂) in liquid or gas phases to verify denitrification pathway completion or identify N₂O accumulation.
Paper claims denitrifiers produce 'nitrogen oxides' that inhibit methanogens, but provides no analytical evidence of which N-species are produced, their concentrations, or whether complete denitrification to N₂ occurs. Section 3.2 states 'the direct mechanism behind these phenomena is yet to be verified'.
Try. Measure NO₃⁻, NO₂⁻, N₂O, and N₂ in reactor A (denitrifier) vs B (control) at each cycle using ion chromatography (liquid) and GC-ECD or GC-MS (gas headspace). Quantify N-balance to confirm complete denitrification.
High No measurement of cathode or anode potential (vs Ag/AgCl or SHE) to characterize electrochemical conditions and assess whether denitrification is electrochemically driven or purely biological.
Only applied potential (0.7 V) is reported; actual cathode and anode potentials are unknown. This prevents assessment of whether denitrification is coupled to cathodic reduction or occurs independently. Denitrifiers may be exoelectrogens themselves.
Try. Install reference electrode (Ag/AgCl) and measure cathode and anode potentials vs SHE at each cycle. Correlate potential windows with H₂ production and N-species accumulation.
Medium No measurement of dissolved oxygen (DO) in reactors to confirm anaerobic conditions and assess whether residual O₂ affects denitrifier activity or methanogen inhibition.
Anaerobic procedure uses N₂ flushing and methylene blue color change as proxy for anoxia, but no quantitative DO measurement. Denitrifiers require anoxia; residual O₂ could shift metabolism and reduce N-oxide production.
Try. Measure dissolved O₂ in reactors A and B at start and end of each cycle using O₂ electrode or optode. Confirm DO < 0.5 mg/L throughout operation.
Medium No measurement of pH in reactors; catholyte pH is critical for denitrification kinetics and methanogen inhibition but is not reported.
Medium formulation is described but pH is not measured or controlled. Denitrification and H₂ production both affect pH; pH drift could explain cycle 3 collapse and cycle 4 recovery.
Try. Measure pH in reactors A and B at each cycle start and end. If pH drifts >0.5 units, add pH control (buffer or acid/base dosing) and repeat cycles 3–4.
Medium No variation of applied potential or current density to identify optimal operating window for simultaneous H₂ production and denitrification-mediated methanogen inhibition.
Only 0.7 V and 1 A tested; no exploration of trade-offs between H₂ yield, denitrification rate, and N₂O accumulation. Higher potentials may increase H₂ production but suppress denitrification; lower potentials may favor denitrification but reduce H₂.
Try. Test applied potentials 0.5, 0.7, 0.9, 1.1 V at constant 1 A in reactors A and B. Measure H₂ yield, N-species, and methanogenic activity (CH₄ production) at each potential.
High No measurement of methane (CH₄) production in reactors to quantify methanogenic suppression and confirm that H₂ improvement is due to reduced methanogenesis rather than increased H₂ evolution.
Paper claims denitrifiers inhibit methanogens, but CH₄ is not measured. H₂ improvement could reflect increased H₂ production, decreased methanogenic consumption, or both. GC analysis includes only H₂ detection.
Try. Modify GC method to detect both H₂ and CH₄ (or use separate FID detector). Measure CH₄ in reactors A and B at each cycle. Calculate net H₂ yield as (H₂ produced) − (H₂ consumed by methanogens).
Generated by MESSAI extraction pipeline · review against source PDF
Extracted values
Every value pulled from the paper, with its source, so each number can be checked against the text.
n = 53 extracted values
Select a citation to see the quote, page and confidence behind a value.
13 of 52 extracted rows modelable
- 28 not canonicalised (no canonical slug)
- 6 no SI value
- 1 not marked applicable to modeling
- 4 contradicts other papers
| Parameter | Value | Unit | Confidence | Source | Notes | Modelable |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Working Volume | 15 | mL | 47% | hybrid | p.76 | |
| Supplied Current | 1 | A | 100% | extracted | "The supplied current is set at 1 A." · substrate=sewage_sludge | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Internal Resistance | 10 | Ω | 100% | extracted | "Between the power supply and the anode, a 10 Ω resistor was used in order to rec…" · substrate=sewage_sludge | Modelable |
| Electrode Surface Area | 0.08 | cm | 100% | extracted | "In order to establish electrical connection with the electrodes, titanium wire (…" · condition_hint=design parameter; Grade 2 titanium wire for anode connection, electrode_material=titanium | Excluded: no SI value |
| Electrode Surface Area | 0.125 | inches | 100% | extracted | "Anodes (A) used were isomolded graphite plates with a thickness of 0.125 inches …" · condition_hint=design parameter; isomolded graphite Grade GM-10, electrode_material=graphite | Excluded: no SI value |
| H₂ Purity | 24.6 | % | 100% | gas chromatography | "On the other hand, both reactor A and B showed peak for hydrogen at around 0.6, …" · substrate=sewage_sludge, steady_state | Excluded: contradicts other papers |
| H₂ Purity | 2.95 | % | 100% | gas chromatography | "Analysis of the headspace taken after 46 hrs of reactor operation is shown in Fi…" · substrate=sewage_sludge, degradation | Excluded: contradicts other papers |
| H₂ Purity | 10.9 | % | 100% | gas chromatography | "On the other hand, both reactor A and B showed peak for hydrogen at around 0.6, …" · substrate=sewage_sludge, steady_state | Excluded: contradicts other papers |
| H₂ Purity | 5.6 | % | 100% | gas chromatography | "On the other hand, both reactor A and B showed peak for hydrogen at around 0.6, …" · substrate=sewage_sludge, steady_state | Excluded: contradicts other papers |
| N₂ Flushing Duration per Cycle | 10 | s | 100% | extracted | "The flushing cycles are as follows: firstly vial is pumped with N2 for 10 s, the…" · condition_hint=anaerobic procedure; first step of flushing cycle | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Wastewater Sludge Volume in Reactor B | 1.5 | ml | 100% | extracted | "The second reactor contains 1.5 ml wastewater sludge and 13.5 ml medium." · substrate=sewage_sludge | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Wastewater Sludge Dilution Factor | 100 | fold | 100% | extracted | "Wastewater sludge was obtained from Waduk Ria Rio (Pulo Mas, Jakarta) to serve a…" · substrate=sewage_sludge | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Final Vacuum Duration | 10 | s | 100% | extracted | "The flushing cycles are as follows: firstly vial is pumped with N2 for 10 s, the…" · condition_hint=anaerobic procedure; third step of flushing cycle | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Internal Resistance Threshold | 2 | Ω | 100% | multimeter | "Internal resistances for the electrodes will then be tested with a multimeter. O…" · condition_hint=design parameter; quality control threshold for electrode selection, electrode_material=graphite anode, stainless steel mesh cathode | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Simultaneous N₂ Pump and Vacuum Duration | 20 | s | 100% | extracted | "The flushing cycles are as follows: firstly vial is pumped with N2 for 10 s, the…" · condition_hint=anaerobic procedure; second step of flushing cycle | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Applied Potential | 0.7 | V | 100% | extracted | "A programmable power supply is used to supply energy to the system in order to d…" · substrate=sewage_sludge | Excluded: not marked applicable to modeling |
| Wire Gauge | 0.08 | cm | 100% | extracted | "In order to establish electrical connection with the electrodes, titanium wire (…" · condition_hint=design parameter; stainless steel wire for cathode connection, electrode_material=stainless steel | Excluded: no SI value |
| Inoculum Volume | 1.5 | ml | 100% | extracted | "The first reactor contains 1.5 ml diluted wastewater sludge, 1.5 ml inoculum, an…" · substrate=sewage_sludge | Modelable |
| H₂ Production Rate | 100 | % | 100% | gas chromatography | "This result proved the hypothesis in which the presence of the denitrifer inside…" · substrate=sewage_sludge, steady_state | Excluded: no SI value |
| Mediator Concentration | 2E-4 | % w/v | 100% | extracted | "The medium used was formulated according to Tugtas (2007) [16] but without the v…" · substrate=sewage_sludge | Excluded: no SI value |
| Electrode Spacing | 0.5 | cm | 100% | extracted | "The electrode spacing is kept at a minimum distance of 0.5-cm." · condition_hint=design parameter; minimum distance between electrodes, electrode_material=graphite anode, stainless steel mesh cathode | Modelable |
| Reactor Volume | 15 | ml | 100% | extracted | "The total working volume is 15 ml, providing headspace for gas to accumulate." · condition_hint=design parameter; single-chambered, membrane-less 20-ml glass vial | Modelable |
| Electrode Thickness | 1.5 | cm | 100% | extracted | "Anodes (A) used were isomolded graphite plates with a thickness of 0.125 inches …" · condition_hint=design parameter; isomolded graphite Grade GM-10, electrode_material=graphite | Modelable |
| Electrode Thickness | 1 | cm | 100% | extracted | "Anodes (A) used were isomolded graphite plates with a thickness of 0.125 inches …" · condition_hint=design parameter; isomolded graphite Grade GM-10, electrode_material=graphite | Modelable |
| Chamber Volume | 13.5 | ml | 100% | extracted | "The second reactor contains 1.5 ml wastewater sludge and 13.5 ml medium." · substrate=sewage_sludge | Modelable |
Methodology
What was the system and how was it run
Methodology
Methodology
Single-chamber, membrane-less MEC reactors (15 ml working volume, 20 ml glass vials) with graphite anode (1.5 × 1.0 cm) and stainless steel cathode (same dimensions) operated at 0.7 V applied potential and 1 A supplied current. Three reactors in parallel: A (wastewater sludge + P. stutzeri denitrifier inoculum + medium), B (wastewater sludge + medium, control), C (medium only, sterile control). Reactors maintained anaerobic via N₂ flushing and vacuum cycles. H₂ composition in headspace measured by gas chromatography (TCD detector, argon carrier) at 69 hrs (cycle 1), 39 hrs (cycle 2), 46 hrs (cycle 3), and 71 hrs (cycle 4). Medium replaced between cycles.
System configuration
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| reactor type | MEC |
| chamber config | 1-chamber |
Operating conditions
11 runs extracted| Run | T°C | pHan | pHcat | Substrate | [S]mg/L | HRTh | Mode | R_extΩ | V_appV | Inoculum |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| v2-0d134d0e35c62b55 | — | — | — | sewage_sludge | — | — | degradation | 10 | 0.7 | — |
| v2-6d9a70da192dbcb1 | — | — | — | sewage_sludge | — | — | steady_state | — | 0.7 | — |
| v2-6e7517478de7c42b | — | — | — | sewage_sludge | — | — | — | 10 | 0.7 | — |
| v2-92e1c64bc8f2f577 | — | — | — | sewage_sludge | — | — | steady_state | 10 | 0.7 | — |
| v2-96c77d8d0ebbb066 | — | — | — | — | — | — | startup | — | — | — |
| v2-9a09096b592e1712 | — | — | — | sewage_sludge | — | — | degradation | — | 0.7 | — |
| v2-a93cfb2f598f325e | — | — | — | sewage_sludge | — | — | — | — | 0.7 | — |
| v2-e386272b44fdc851 | — | — | — | sewage_sludge | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| v2-f586e9af22985397 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| v2-f93c309e9b6c7f60 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | 0.7 | — |
| v2-ff5348c538bb29e6 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | 10 | — | — |
Pipeline
Raw extractions, artifacts, quality signal
Extraction quality
honesty signalCalibrate your trust in the extracted content against these signals — they're how the pipeline rated its own output for this paper.
Parameter completeness
38%
Fraction of expected parameters extracted
Data completeness
60%
Overall extraction coverage across fields
AI confidence
72%
Model self-reported confidence
Mean parameter confidence
64%
Average confidence across PaperParameter rows surfaced above
review against source PDF before citing · scores 0–1
Chart explorer
Move the inputs this paper used and see how the predicted outcome shifts.
Explore model
The reactor in 3D, with flow you can switch on and off.
AI insights
Contradictions, gaps and opportunities found by comparing this paper with the corpus.
Compare similar papers
The nearest papers by system, materials and organisms, with their outcomes side by side.
Source PDF
The paper as published.
Representative model, generic MEC
Tap to interactRepresentative model, generic MEC
Representative MEC — matched on the paper’s system type only, not its reactor or geometry.
Keywords
- Biohydrogen
- Methanogenesis
- Methanogen
- Microbial electrolysis cell
- Hydrogen production
- Hydrogen
Cite
Matthew Hardhi, Putty Ekadewi, Rita Arbianti et al. (2018). Improvement of biohydrogen production in microbial electrolysis cell (MEC) system by tackling methanogenesis. E3S Web of Conferences. https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/20186702008
- Journal
- E3S Web of Conferences
Open in lab for full controls, parameter editing, and template overlays.
Open in lab