Research

Paper · MNRC

Microalgae- and biochar-mediated wastewater treatment: augmentation of bioelectrochemical nitrogen removal and biogas production

01

Summary

What the paper reports, in its own words.

AI Enhanced· 72%Substrate ·synthetic mixtureWastewater TreatmentResource Recovery

Abstract

Abstract Bioelectrochemical systems can recover energy while treating wastewater as an attractive form of bioengineering technology. This research devised a novel upgraded system that can remove a high proportion of nitrogen (N) from wastewater and produce biogas. We investigated the scale-up effect of mixing ammonia-nitrogen (NH 3 -N) and nitrate-nitrogen (NO 3 -N) under anoxic conditions, and we also assessed the mediation-impact of Chlorella vulgaris (C. vulgaris) and carbon-based biocatalyst (biochar). The experiment was carried out using three independent batches, and each lasted for 35 d. The results showed that the unique enhanced system could simultaneously remove more than 90% of NH 3 and NO 3 from wastewater and generate a significant amount of N 2 O, CH 4, and CO 2 . In addition, dominant bacteria genera such as Sporosarcina, Tissieralla , and Pseudomonas have played a robust role in N removal and biogas generation. Compared to past studies, the unique enhanced system significantly improved the N removal efficiency of the bioelectrochemical systems.

AI summary

72% confidence

This dual-chamber bioelectrochemical system achieved 90–99% removal of NH3-N (11.6–17.1 mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹) and NO3-N (12.3–13 mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹) under anoxic anode conditions with a 1.33 NH3/NO3 ratio. Chlorella vulgaris in the cathode reduced NH4⁺ accumulation from 8.81 to 3.35 mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹, while biochar suppressed NH4⁺ migration and lowered NH3-N removal to 67%. N2O was a major product (6–48%), and Firmicutes and Proteobacteria dominated the microbial community. The system generated 51–180 mL biogas per day across conditions.

Key insights

  • Trade-off Biochar in the cathode chamber reduced NH4⁺ accumulation from 8.81 to 3.73 mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹ but simultaneously decreased NH3-N removal efficiency from 96–97% to 67%, revealing a trade-off between ammonia recovery and removal.

    So what. Operators must choose between maximizing N removal (avoid biochar) or recovering ammonia (add biochar), depending on treatment goal; biochar is not universally beneficial.

  • Mechanism C. vulgaris in the cathode reduced NH4⁺ accumulation to 3.35 mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹ (62% reduction vs. control) while maintaining 97% NO3-N and 94% NH3-N removal, indicating algal assimilation is compatible with high N removal.

    So what. Integrate microalgae into cathode design to simultaneously achieve high N removal and reduce ammonia volatilization risk without sacrificing treatment efficiency.

  • Threshold NO3-N removal efficiency reached 99% in batch C (with biochar) while NH3-N removal dropped to 67%, showing that high electron acceptor consumption does not guarantee balanced dual-N removal.

    So what. Monitor both N species simultaneously; preferential NO3-N reduction under certain conditions (biochar, low AnB activity) can starve NH3-N removal pathways.

  • Trade-off N2O production ranged from 6% (biochar, C2) to 48% (C. vulgaris, B1), indicating that cathode amendments dramatically shift denitrification selectivity toward N2O rather than N2.

    So what. If N2O minimization is critical, avoid C. vulgaris in the cathode; biochar suppresses N2O formation, possibly by altering redox conditions or microbial community structure.

  • Mechanism Anammox bacteria were outcompeted by heterotrophic denitrifiers in the first week; NO3-N removal was exceedingly slow initially despite continuous input, suggesting a lag phase before AnB enrichment.

    So what. Design startup protocols to suppress heterotrophs (e.g., limit organic carbon, extend acclimation) if AnB-mediated N removal is desired; otherwise, accept heterotrophic denitrification as the dominant pathway.

Contradictions1

Tensions the paper itself points to. Each side quotes the passage it comes from.

  • Within the paper Biochar simultaneously improves NO3-N removal but impairs NH3-N removal, yet both are fed at a fixed 1.33 ratio.

    One side

    NO3-N removal efficiency in batch C = 99% (highest across all batches)

    “In addition, the mixture of electron donors and acceptors present in the B1 had resulted in rapid NO3-N depletion with a removal efficiency of 99%.”
    Other side

    NH3-N removal efficiency in batch C = 67% (lowest across all batches)

    “In contrast, a decrease to 67% in NH3-N removal efficiency was detected (Fig. 2d).”

    Authors’ reading. Authors attribute this to biochar's inhibition of NH4⁺ migration and suppression of nitrification/ammonification (Section 3.2.2), suggesting biochar alters the microbial community or redox environment to favor denitrification over nitrification. The fixed N ratio means NO3-N is consumed faster than NH3-N is oxidized, creating an imbalance.

Opportunity areas6

Specific gaps in this paper, with an experiment that would close each.

  • High No explicit measurement of cathode potential, anode potential, or applied voltage; operating window for electrode potentials is not defined.

    The paper states 'Electrode spacing and surface area, COD and DO levels, and NH3-N concentration all have a massive effect on the removal efficacy of N' (Section 3.2.4) but does not report the potentials or current density used, making it impossible to replicate or optimize the system.

    Try. Vary cathode potential from −0.5 to −1.0 V vs. Ag/AgCl and anode potential from +0.2 to +0.8 V; measure NH3-N, NO3-N, and N2O at each potential; identify the window that maximizes N2 while minimizing N2O.

  • High Dissolved oxygen (DO) in the anode is reported as 0–0.9 mg L⁻¹ but not controlled; no systematic study of DO effect on N removal or N2O selectivity.

    Section 3.2.4 cites Jiang et al. showing N removal efficiency dropped from 87.42% to 75.39% when DO increased from 4.0 to 7.0 mg L⁻¹, yet this paper does not control or vary anode DO, only reports it passively.

    Try. Maintain anode DO at 0, 0.5, 1.0, 2.0, and 4.0 mg L⁻¹ using N2 sparging or air injection; measure NH3-N, NO3-N, N2O, and microbial community composition at each DO level.

  • Medium Hydraulic retention time (HRT) is not varied; all batches run for 35 d with continuous NO3-N input at 0.04 mL min⁻¹ but no measurement of actual HRT or effect of HRT on N removal kinetics.

    The paper does not report reactor volume, flow rate, or calculated HRT; batch operation with continuous input makes HRT ambiguous. No comparison of short vs. long HRT.

    Try. Test HRT of 2, 5, 10, and 20 d by varying influent flow rate; measure NH3-N and NO3-N removal efficiency and N2O yield at each HRT.

  • Medium Catholyte pH is not controlled or systematically varied; anode pH drops from 8.11–9.31 to 6.57–6.98 over 35 d but cathode pH is not reported.

    Section 3.2.4 shows anode pH dynamics but no cathode pH data; C. vulgaris growth and NH4⁺ assimilation are pH-sensitive, yet no pH control strategy is described.

    Try. Maintain cathode pH at 6.5, 7.0, 7.5, 8.0, and 8.5 using buffer or acid/base dosing; measure C. vulgaris growth rate, NH4⁺ accumulation, and N2O production at each pH.

  • Medium C/N ratio is not explicitly controlled or varied; glucose is provided at 500 mg L⁻¹ in artificial medium but no measurement of actual COD or C/N ratio during operation.

    Section 3.2.3 states 'organic compounds must provide adequate electron donors before NO3 removal in WWTPs may be considered practical' but the paper does not test different C/N ratios or measure residual COD.

    Try. Vary initial glucose concentration from 250 to 1000 mg L⁻¹ (C/N ratio ~0.5 to 2.0); measure NH3-N, NO3-N, N2O, and residual COD over time.

  • Medium N2O is quantified as a percentage of biogas but not as a mass or molar flux; no measurement of N2O accumulation in headspace or dissolved N2O in liquid.

    Table 5 reports N2O as 6–48% of biogas volume but does not convert to mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹ or compare to N removal rates; unclear if N2O is a major N loss pathway or minor byproduct.

    Try. Measure N2O concentration in biogas by GC-MS; calculate N2O-N flux in mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹; compare to NH3-N and NO3-N removal rates to close the N balance.

Generated by MESSAI extraction pipeline · review against source PDF

02

Extracted values

Every value pulled from the paper, with its source, so each number can be checked against the text.

n = 70 extracted values

Select a citation to see the quote, page and confidence behind a value.

31 of 69 extracted rows modelable

  • 13 not canonicalised (no canonical slug)
  • 25 no SI value
ParameterValueUnitConfidenceSourceNotesModelable
Substratewastewater—80%
llm
Total Nitrogen Removal99%95%
apha standard method 4500-no3
"In addition, the mixture of electron donors and acceptors present in the B1 had …" · pH(an)=7.3, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
Total Nitrogen Removal67%95%
apha standard method 4500-nh3 d
"In addition, the mixture of electron donors and acceptors present in the B1 had …" · pH(an)=7.3, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
Total Nitrogen Removal97%95%
apha standard method 4500-nh3 d
"The mixing of NH3-N and NO3-N in the B1 showed a 97% and 94% removal efficiency,…" · pH(an)=7.4, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
Total Nitrogen Removal96%95%
apha standard method 4500-nh3 d
"In this batch, we kept the ratio of NH3-N and NO3-N applied into the anolyte to …" · pH(an)=7.5, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
Total Nitrogen Removal95%95%
apha standard method 4500-no3
"In this batch, we kept the ratio of NH3-N and NO3-N applied into the anolyte to …" · pH(an)=7.5, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
Total Nitrogen Removal94%95%
apha standard method 4500-no3
"The mixing of NH3-N and NO3-N in the B1 showed a 97% and 94% removal efficiency,…" · pH(an)=7.4, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
Total Suspended Solids1,650mg L⁻¹90%
apha standard method 2540 d
"The concentrations fell dramatically until stabilizing at 700 mg L− 1, 1650 mg L…" · pH(an)=7.4, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
pH7.5—90%
portable ph meter apha standard method
"The BR had an average pH of 7.5 0.6 and a DO of 0 to 0.9 mg L− 1 in the anolyte …" · pH(an)=7.5, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
pH7.4—90%
portable ph meter apha standard method
"On the other hand, the average pH value in the second batch was 7.4 ± 0.33." · pH(an)=7.4, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
pH7.3—90%
portable ph meter apha standard method
"However, in the third batch, all anodic activities of microorganisms in the slud…" · pH(an)=7.3, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
N2O production percentage48%90%
gas chromatography apha method 2720 c
"In contrast, the highest N2O production was detected in B1 (48%), followed by A1…" · pH(an)=7.4, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateExcluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug)
Total Organic Carbon6,100mg L⁻¹90%
apha standard method 2540 d
"In the first, second, and third successive batches, we started the bioelectroche…" · pH(an)=7.5, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, startupModelable
Ammonium Recovery3.35mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹90%
daily sampling and apha standard method 4500-nh3 d
"The average daily production witnessed was 8.81 ± 6.53 mg N L− 1, 3.35 ± 1.85 mg…" · pH(an)=7.4, substrate=bgedium_with_c._vulgaris, steady_stateExcluded: no SI value
Biofilm Coverage57.1%90%
16s rrna gene sequencing and metagenome analysis
"This study found that the 1st dominant phylum identified from the OTUs taxa in a…" · pH(an)=7.5, substrate=artificial_medium, steady_stateModelable
Operational Taxonomic Units230OTUs90%
16s rrna gene sequencing and rarefaction analysis
"Furthermore, we plotted the rank-abundance distribution curve, and the number of…" · pH(an)=7.5, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
Total Organic Carbon5,800mg L⁻¹90%
apha standard method 2540 d
"In the first, second, and third successive batches, we started the bioelectroche…" · pH(an)=7.3, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, startupModelable
Biofilm Coverage46.5%90%
16s rrna gene sequencing and metagenome analysis
"This study found that the 1st dominant phylum identified from the OTUs taxa in a…" · pH(an)=7.4, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
Biofilm Coverage56.6%90%
16s rrna gene sequencing and metagenome analysis
"This study found that the 1st dominant phylum identified from the OTUs taxa in a…" · pH(an)=7.5, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
Total Suspended Solids1,500mg L⁻¹90%
apha standard method 2540 d
"The concentrations fell dramatically until stabilizing at 700 mg L− 1, 1650 mg L…" · pH(an)=7.3, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
CH₄ Content Biogas0.2%90%
gas chromatography apha method 2720 c
"The sample of methane gas taken from B1 (24%) was also the highest in this group…" · pH(an)=7.4, substrate=bgedium_with_c._vulgaris, steady_stateModelable
Total Suspended Solids700mg L⁻¹90%
apha standard method 2540 d
"The concentrations fell dramatically until stabilizing at 700 mg L− 1, 1650 mg L…" · pH(an)=7.5, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
Relative Abundance10%90%
16s rrna gene sequencing and metagenome analysis
"and Planctomycetota (10.02%, 6.31%, 8.57%, 4.44%, 1.99%, and 1.78%) in sample A1…" · pH(an)=7.5, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
Relative Abundance50%90%
16s rrna gene sequencing and metagenome analysis
"This study found that the 1st dominant phylum identified from the OTUs taxa in a…" · pH(an)=7.4, substrate=bgedium_with_c._vulgaris, steady_stateModelable
Relative Abundance16.7%90%
16s rrna gene sequencing and metagenome analysis
"followed by Proteobacteria (16.65%, 20.54%, 25.6%, 21.01%, and 22.07%), and Plan…" · pH(an)=7.5, substrate=artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n, steady_stateModelable
Showing 25 of 70

Methodology

What was the system and how was it run

Methodology

Methodology

Three dual-chamber bioelectrochemical reactors (4500 mL, graphite anode, stainless-steel cathode, Nafion CEM) were operated in batch mode for 35 d with activated sludge inoculum. Batch A (control): sludge + artificial medium + NH3-N (600 mg N L⁻¹) + NO3-N (450 mg N L⁻¹, 1.33 ratio). Batch B: B1 identical to A1; B2 with C. vulgaris in BG11 medium. Batch C: C1 identical to A1; C2 with biochar in cathode. Daily sampling measured NH3-N, NO3-N, pH, DO, TSS by APHA methods. Biogas composition (CH4, CO2, N2O) analyzed by GC. Microbial community profiled by 16S rRNA sequencing at day 35.

System configuration

FieldValue
reactor typeBES
chamber config2-chamber

Electrode specifications

FieldValue
materials["biochar"]

Biological parameters

FieldValue
dominant species["Pseudomonas"]

Operational parameters

FieldValue
substrate["wastewater"]

Operating conditions

18 runs extracted
RunT°CpHanpHcatSubstrate[S]mg/LHRThModeR_extΩV_appVInoculum
v2-01e2debb5e8aeceb—7.3—artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n450—steady_state———
v2-08adcdca6fd520c2—7.3—artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n——steady_state———
v2-090187af0f550b89—7.4—artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n——steady_state———
v2-0b85281c2c7d6276—7.4—bgedium_with_c._vulgaris——steady_state———
v2-12629686946220e0—7.3—artificial_medium_with_biochar——steady_state———
v2-28ffae4d15783e97—7.5—artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n——startup———
v2-2f6b8ef35f4e8028—7.3—artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n600—steady_state———
v2-37fa713ff0ee66e2—7.5—artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n450—steady_state———
v2-4c335f070c1bf690—7.4—artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n——startup———
v2-6691a3f1d7b0394a257—bgedium——steady_state———
v2-750768d26fb1a3fc—7.4—artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n450—steady_state———
v2-7dff617410035df6—7.5—artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n600—steady_state———
v2-814661a9cd567073—7.3—artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n——startup———
v2-8ff823bdedf95d6b—7.4—artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n600—steady_state———
v2-a2555c3774c4e108—7.5—artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n——steady_state———
v2-b4978deb0adb6f9a257.5—artificial_medium_with_nh3-n_and_no3-n450—steady_state———
v2-ebba596fc1b2ebfa—7.5—artificial_medium——steady_state———
v2-f4086ea693cbb310257—bgedium——startup———

Pipeline

Raw extractions, artifacts, quality signal

Extraction quality

honesty signal

Calibrate your trust in the extracted content against these signals — they're how the pipeline rated its own output for this paper.

Parameter completeness

38%

Fraction of expected parameters extracted

Data completeness

40%

Overall extraction coverage across fields

AI confidence

72%

Model self-reported confidence

Mean parameter confidence

89%

Average confidence across PaperParameter rows surfaced above

review against source PDF before citing · scores 0–1

03

Chart explorer

Move the inputs this paper used and see how the predicted outcome shifts.

04

Explore model

The reactor in 3D, with flow you can switch on and off.

05

AI insights

Contradictions, gaps and opportunities found by comparing this paper with the corpus.

06

Compare similar papers

The nearest papers by system, materials and organisms, with their outcomes side by side.

07

Source PDF

The paper as published.

No 3D model is mapped to this paper yet. The values extracted from it are listed under Extracted values.

MNRC
System
70
Extracted values
2022
Year

Keywords

  • Biochar
  • Biogas
  • Wastewater
  • Sewage treatment
  • Biogas production
  • Production (economics)

Cite

Deqiang Chen, Muhammad Ibrahim, Ran Tian et al. (2022). Microalgae- and biochar-mediated wastewater treatment: augmentation of bioelectrochemical nitrogen removal and biogas production. Research Square. https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-1531440/v1